Experiential and Applied Learning
  • 2024 Study Abroad to Singapore
  • Home
  • Higher Education Topics - Blog
  • Applied and Experiential Learning - Blog
  • Research & Teaching Critical Thinking - Blog
  • About
  • Media Coverage
  • Experiential and Applied Learning Examples
    • Experiential Learning Vietnam 2017
    • Monopoly for Teamwork
    • Learning in Hanoi
    • Hanoi Community Service
    • Saigon Starbucks Experience
    • Saigon Class Concert
    • Outside the Classroom

More about Academic Integrity in Our Changed World

6/15/2020

0 Comments

 
Picture
Please take two minutes to read the article at this link from a Singapore newspaper:

"NUS students get zero marks for cheating on take-home exam"

As students take more college courses online, either fully or in a hybrid seated+online configuration, getting the students to maintain academic integrity increases dramatically. It simply is too easy for a student to cheat if they are taking an exam or writing a paper online with no oversight -- i.e., without proctoring. Why does this matter to me? Two simple reasons:

Students who study to learn the material feel cheated by students who collaborate or plagiarize on exams.
  1. Some students -- think nurses, accountants, engineers, doctors, and other professional practitioners -- will be expected to have actually learned what they studied when they start to practice medicine, design buildings and bridges, or handle corporate and personal accounts.
  2. In a recent year, partway through a semester in a capstone strategic management course I taught in Singapore, I was talking with my students about academic integrity. One student raised his hand and I called on him. He said, and this is a verbatim quote: "Professor, it isn't cheating if you don't get caught." This actually happened!

After discovering that exam scores were significantly higher -- i.e., 20% or more higher -- with online multiple-choice question (MCQ) exams, I did an experiment in one of these capstone courses. I put a low-stakes MCQ exam online, scheduling it to be open for 30 minutes during a regular seated class session. The exam was intended to be taken independently, not collaboratively. The students had ten minutes to complete the exam during the 30-minute window. They started in the classroom, and then could go wherever they wanted to complete the exam during that 30-minute window.

I gave the students a countdown to the start of the exam, and the second the exam window opened, about 75% of the students ran out of the classroom to the tables in the hallways to form groups to take the exam together. The remaining 25% of the students stayed in the classroom. I had told everyone that they should take the exam the way the normally would, so they did. One group at a large table had a single student take the exam during the first 10-minute block and watched that student, advising him if he was unsure of the answer. When he finished they regrouped into three smaller groups and then watched and advised the one student in their smaller group has he or she took the exam. Finally, the remaining students went to their computers to take the exam in the last 10-minute block, with the students who had completed the exam watching and helping.

I knew this behavior existed from a few years back, when I discovered extremely high scores on a Masters-level online exam that -- are you ready for this -- nursing students were taking. Eventually, one of the students in the class complained. To her -- she had studied hard for the exam and had taken it by herself as instructed -- it was unfair that other students had high grades without actually learning the material. She had observed students in her class taking the exam in teams at computers in the library.

Many of my friends feel it is unfair to use plagiarism checking tools, or online exam monitoring tools. We would proctor the exam in the classroom. Why should we not proctor it online? And how do we treat the students who learn the material who feel cheated by the students who do not learn but plagiarize or get help during online exams?

Of course, we could stop giving MCQ exams. But students can cheat in online essays or open-ended question exams just as easily. I use the MCQ exams only to confirm that the students are reading and understanding the course material. I even give the students the subject of every question on the exam a week ahead. These exams account for a relatively small portion of the final grade. If I catch a student cheating on one of these, the student most likely will fail the course. But I need the monitoring tools for online exams to catch the cheating. (And yes, I use question pools and random question delivery to limit cheating. I've had a student answer a write-in question that wasn't on his delivered online exam because someone else had told him the question that the other student had received and this student gave the answer to that question.)

I use Project-Based-Learning methods with students working together all semester in teams. We could just give team-based grades. But if you teach, you know there are a lot of social loafers who expect the other team members to do the work, but expect the same grades as their team members.

I hate online exam monitoring. We must use it; out of fairness to students who try to learn the material, and because students will be expected to know what we teach when they start their careers.

This article, about online cheating in an Engineering program at the National University of Singapore (NUS), illustrates the problem. Congratulations to NUS both for giving the students zero grades, and noted their academic integrity failure in their permanent records. If we sanction students for cheating, and have ways to identify cheating, we may be able to reduce the "It isn't cheating if you don't get caught" mentality.


#college #highereducation #academicintegrity #integrity #honesty #onlineeducation #onlineexam
0 Comments

Entrepreneurship Project-based learning in Singapore

11/16/2018

0 Comments

 
Picture
Thank you to Avis Easteal, #Luxasia Regional Head of Consumer. Avis joined our University at Buffalo, Singapore, Entrepreneurship students to talk about marketing on Friday, November 9, 2018.
My wife and I met Mrs. Easteal by chance over the weekend. We learned how she and her company market based on data analysis and delivering superior customer experiences. Her talk with the class brought what my students had been studying had been studying to life. The sample perfumes she handed out brightened up the room.
This Entrepreneurship class incorporates Project-Based Learning (PBL). During the first week of the semester, the students form teams and decide on a business idea they want to develop. Throughout the semester, we intersperse readings and lectures on business processes, especially as they relate to startups. The students apply what they are learning to the creation of a business plan that includes financial, operations, and marketing plans. They create an investor pitch that the teams deliver in the final week of class.
Many students commented in their weekly journal entries that Mrs. Easteal's discussion of delivering customer experiences, and of gathering and using customer data effectively, applied to their projects, giving them new ideas. Mrs. Easteal also took time to meet with each of the teams to review their business ideas and to give them feedback. The weekly journal entries that week indicated that many of the teams benefited from her feedback.
Is a guest lecture or presentation experiential learning? The evidence from this activity indicates that when the students can connect the presentation content to their projects, what they learn from the presentation enhances their learning from the projects.
0 Comments

Strategic management PBL in singapore

10/30/2018

0 Comments

 
This is an example of Project-Based Learning.

The strategic management students are working on final presentations of their three-year strategic plan outcomes within a global strategy simulation in an athletic shoe industry. This is a semester-long project, culminating in the final presentation of the analysis of the strategic plan outcomes.

The teacher (i.e., me) ceases to be the "sage on the stage" and becomes a consultant. The teacher visits the student teams, and the students come for advice and consultation.

Both strategy classes this semester have been fully engaged, and their results within the simulation have been outstanding.
0 Comments

Project-Based Learning in Singapore with indra Wijaya

9/12/2018

0 Comments

 
Entrepreneur and educator Indra Wijaya visited my University at Buffalo Entrepreneurship & Small Business class in Singapore this morning. He talked about the business he has started, and he worked with some of the project teams.
The students have grouped into their course-long working teams. Each team has a leader who wishes to develop a business plan for a new business.
0 Comments
    View my profile on LinkedIn

      Subscribe by email

    Subscribe to Newsletter

    Paul McAfee

    My experiential learning Activities blog includes examples from my international teaching experiences. The Research blog includes studies I have read and comments on others' research, as well as my own.

    Read about examples from my teaching college business courses in China, Singapore, the United States, and Vietnam, relating to both experiential learning and project-based learning.

    Please share your questions and thoughts here.

    Archives

    November 2023
    September 2023
    March 2023
    June 2022
    May 2022
    November 2021
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    October 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    November 2013

    Categories

    All
    Active Learning
    Canisius College
    Daemen College
    Diversity
    Drone Racing
    Experiential Learning
    Generation Z
    Global Strategy
    Higher Education
    Keuka College
    #Luxasia
    Millennials
    Nonbinary Gender Pronouns
    Paul McAfee
    Project Based Learning
    Project-Based Learning
    School Of Management
    Singapore
    STEM
    Strategic Management
    Transgender Terminology
    UNC Asheville
    University At Buffalo
    Vietnam

    RSS Feed

Copyright 2013-2023 Paul McAfee
LinkedIn Profile: www.linkedin.com/in/paulmcafee